Having Disastrously Shut Down the Government for Two Extended Periods This Congress and Achieving None of Their Stated Goals, Senate Democrats Are Debating Whether to Take the Plunge for a Third Time
OVER THE LAST WEEK, SENATE REPUBLICAN APPROPRIATORS RELEASED FY2027 FUNDING BILLS AS THE DECEMBER 11 GOVERNMENT FUNDING DEADLINE APPROACHES
“I’m increasingly concerned that the Democrats may try to initiate another, a third – third – government shutdown this year… We’ve already had two long, extended government shutdowns. We saw the impact that has on the American people. The American people don’t need another government shutdown. And we need to make sure that people are getting paid, we’re keeping this government open and operating, and we’re going to do everything to ensure that that happens and work with our Democrat colleagues to ensure that there is not a government shutdown.” – Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.)
- “Congress remains at an impasse on how to fund the government just one month away from the deadline to avoid a shutdown ahead of the holidays.” (The Washington Post: One month from shutdown, Congress is far from a deal to fund government – 11/11/26)
- “A growing number of Democrats are convinced they should use the Dec. 11 deadline to choke off funding for what they see as an illegal and unauthorized war.” (Punchbowl News: AM: Is the government shutting down? – 11/18/26)
- Over the past week, in an effort to responsibly fund the entire government ahead of the December 11 deadline, Senate Appropriations Committee Republicans have released all 12 FY2027 funding bills. (U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations: Senate Appropriations Committee Releases Two FY 2027 Funding Bills: Agriculture; Military Construction and Veterans Affairs – 11/10/26; U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations: Senate Appropriations Committee Releases Five FY 2027 Funding Bills – 11/12/26; U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations: Senate Appropriations Committee Releases Final Five FY 2027 Funding Bills – 11/16/26)
- These bills contain vital priorities for Americans:
- “The defense bill, rolled out by Senate Appropriations Committee Republicans, features $202.9 billion for payment and benefits for service members and families to fund a 3.6 percent pay raise, $47.2 billion for munitions procurement and acceleration investments across the Pentagon, and $35.6 billion for investments in air and missile defense capabilities, including the Golden Dome, a priority for President Trump.” (The Hill: Senate GOP unveils nearly $1.1 trillion defense appropriations bill – 11/16/26)
- “The Military Construction, Veterans Affairs, and Related Agencies appropriations bill for Fiscal Year 2027 provides a base discretionary total of $173.2 billion. The bill fully funds veteran medical care and benefits, provides for critical improvements to VA infrastructure and technology systems, and makes a generational investment in military facilities, while improving readiness and quality of life for service members and their families.” (U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations: Senate Appropriations Committee Releases Two FY 2027 Funding Bills: Agriculture; Military Construction and Veterans Affairs – 11/10/26)
- “The Energy and Water Development Appropriations bill for Fiscal Year 2027 provides a base discretionary total of $63.1 billion in funding. The bill funds activities to modernize the U.S. nuclear deterrent, advance America’s energy independence, and improve water infrastructure across the country.” (U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations: Senate Appropriations Committee Releases Five FY 2027 Funding Bills – 11/12/26)
HAVING NOT LEARNED THEIR LESSON FROM PAST SHUTDOWNS WHERE DEMOCRATS ACHIEVED NONE OF THEIR STATED POLICY GOALS, SENATE DEMOCRATS REFUSE TO ENGAGE IN THE REGULAR APPROPRIATIONS PROCESS, AS PROGRESSIVES ARE ITCHING TO SHUT DOWN THE GOVERNMENT INSTEAD
- Democrats instigated two unprecedented government shutdowns this Congress (76-day partial and 43-day full). Both times, Democrats failed to achieve any of their stated policy goals:
- 43-Day Full Shutdown: “Democrats across the country are furious at their party for agreeing to reopen the federal government without key health care demands, and they’re taking it out largely on Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.).” (HuffPost: Knives Are Out For Chuck Schumer After Democrats Cave On Shutdown – 11/10/25)
- 76-Day Partial Shutdown: “Democrats didn’t extract a single significant concession from Republicans, so this was nothing more than a political exercise.” (Punchbowl News: AM: Senate passes DHS funding — without ICE and CBP – 3/27/26)
- To overcome Democrats’ refusal to fund border enforcement, Congressional Republicans passed the Secure America Act, “a roughly $70 billion package to fund ICE and the Border Patrol through the end of President Donald Trump’s term.” (NBC News: Republicans pass bill to fund ICE and Border Patrol through the end of Trump’s term – 6/9/26; U.S. Congress: S. 2 – Secure America Act – accessed 11/18/26)
- Despite failing to achieve their stated policy goals from twice shutting down the government this Congress, “[s]ome Senate Democrats are looking to use a looming government funding deadline to force the Trump administration to end the war in Iran.” (The Hill: Senate Democrats weigh December funding deadline to force an end to Iran war – 11/12/26)
- “While Republicans remain in charge, Democratic leaders are under intense pressure to use their spending powers to end hostilities — potentially sparking a government shutdown.” (Politico: Democrats eye spring government funding punt – 11/12/26)
- “[S]hutdowns are easy to get into, but they’re very hard to get out of. The question right now for the Democratic leadership is how do they anticipate getting out of a shutdown if they provoke one?” (Punchbowl News: AM: Is the government shutting down? – 11/18/26)
- “Some members say they should use the funding deadline as leverage.” (The Hill: Senate Democrats weigh December funding deadline to force an end to Iran war – 11/12/26)
- “Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., said Thursday he is working on legislative language ending the war that he wants attached to the next continuing resolution that is needed by Dec. 11, when current funding runs out. ‘I know it’s going to be my main push,’ he said.” (Roll Call: Democrats mulling Iran war funding cutoff strategy – 11/12/26)
- “Democratic Sens. Michael Bennet of Colorado, Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, Tammy Duckworth of Illinois and independent Bernie Sanders of Vermont released a statement Thursday that they would oppose any deal that does not include ‘language that restricts the Trump Administration from using appropriated funds to continue his war against Iran.’” (Roll Call: Democrats mulling Iran war funding cutoff strategy – 11/12/26)
THE PREVIOUS TWO DEMOCRAT SHUTDOWNS THIS CONGRESS LEFT A LASTING IMPACT ON AIR TRAVEL, GOVERNMENT WORKERS, AND MILITARY FAMILIES
- Democrats’ previous full government shutdown crippled air travel. Orchestrating another full government shutdown will only cause more havoc:
- “For many Americans, the turmoil in the airports became one of the most visible impacts of the 43-day shutdown.” (Politico: Trump administration ends flight cuts at busy airports – 11/16/25)
- “Absences of air traffic controllers led to tens of thousands of flight cancellations and delays after October 1, when the shutdown began.” (Reuters: FAA to end mandated cuts in domestic US flights – 11/17/25)
- The FAA will continue to be short-staffed: “Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said… that ‘15 to 20’ air traffic controllers are retiring daily amid the government shutdown.” (The Hill: Duffy: ’15 to 20′ air traffic controllers retiring daily during shutdown – 11/9/25)
- “The U.S. has been scrambling to hire more air traffic controllers for years… A government tally [in 2024] showed the U.S. was short 3,903 fully certified air traffic controllers of a goal of 14,633.” (CNBC: The government shutdown is over. The air traffic controller shortage is not – 11/15/25)
- In addition to crippling air traffic control, Democrats’ shutdown also harmed government workers and military families: (The Wall Street Journal: Senators to Suspend Their Pay During Government Shutdowns – 5/14/26)
- Between both of Democrats’ government shutdowns, over 2,200 officers at the Transportation Security Administration quit their jobs. (Politico: Over 1,000 TSA officers have quit amid shutdown – 4/27/26)
- Last October, National Guard “officers argue[d] the shutdown has been uniquely challenging for personnel across the country who have not been paid in the month of October if they are not on active duty. The Guard also voiced concern about the prolonged shutdown’s impact on readiness.” (The Daily Caller: ‘Not Good’: National Guard Training Grinds To Halt Amid Shutdown — With No Pay In Sight – 10/22/25)
- “One federal employee said she was dismayed to need to ask for help for the first time. ‘I’ve not been in this predicament ever. I served 21 years in the military. I’ve been a federal government employee for the past two years. The reason I wanted to become a federal government employee was stability. That stability, that rug, if you will, has been snatched away from us,’ she said.” (NBC News: Furloughed fed says she’s standing in Maryland food bank line after 21 years in military – 10/22/25)